The French and the Caro-Kann
Two solid answers to the king's pawn, one square apart, and the bishop on c8 that makes them so different.
Two solid answers
If the Sicilian is a fight from move one, these two are the opposite. Both let White have the centre for a moment, and then challenge it with the d-pawn, backed by a pawn beside it.
- The French Defence backs it with the e-pawn.
- The Caro-Kann backs it with the c-pawn.
One square's difference, and it decides the character of the whole game, because of one piece: Black's bishop on c8.
The French: a chain and a break
White often answers by pushing past: the e-pawn to e5. Now the centre is blocked, and you know how to read it from Making a plan. Black's pawns point at the queen's side, so Black plays there, and the break is the c-pawn against the base of White's chain on d4.
The price is the bishop. Shut in behind e6 and d5, it's the bad bishop of that lesson, and French players spend whole games finding it a job. In return they get a position that's very hard to break down, and a clear plan from the third move.
Try it: the French main line
White's other main choice is to defend the e-pawn with a knight. You're Black. Make White push anyway, and then hit the base.
Try it: the Caro-Kann
The Caro-Kann backs the d-pawn with the c-pawn, and so the diagonal from c8 stays open. The bishop comes out before the e-pawn moves, exactly as in Good and bad bishops.
You're Black again, against the same knight move. This time, swap in the centre and develop the bishop with gain of time.
Try it: the Caro-Kann's own trap
Solid openings have traps too. In this line Black has developed a knight to d7 first, and then the other to f6, which looks as natural as a move can.
You're White. Look at Black's king, and count its squares.
Which is yours?
- The French, if you like a blocked centre and a plan you can follow, and don't mind nursing a bishop.
- The Caro-Kann, if you want every piece on a good square and are happy to wait for your chances. It's the safest reply to the king's pawn there is.
- Either, over the open games, if the tricks around f7 in the sharp Italian lines aren't to your taste: there aren't any here.
Put one in your repertoire on By the book, and it comes back to be played from memory at longer and longer waits.