Good and bad bishops
A bishop is as good as its own pawns let it be: which colour to put them on, getting the bishop out first, and bishop against knight.
A piece that sees half the board
A bishop never leaves the colour it starts on. That one fact decides how good it is, because its own pawns can stand on that colour too, and a pawn doesn't move out of the way.
- A good bishop has its own pawns, the centre pawns above all, on the other colour. Its diagonals are clear, and between them the bishop and the pawns cover squares of both colours.
- A bad bishop has its own pawns fixed on its colour. They stand in its way, and every square of the other colour is left to the opponent.
The two bishops in this picture are both White's, and worth three points each by the book. One of them is doing a pawn's job.
Try it: which bishop is bad?
Three boards, each with a white bishop and a black one. Look at the centre pawns of each side, and at which colour of square they stand on.
Try it: out before the door shuts
That third board is the point of a move you've already played. In the London System the bishop goes to f4 before the pawn goes to e3, so that it ends up outside the pawns.
The same idea runs through many openings. Here you're Black, three moves in. White's pawn has gone to e5 and yours stands on d5, a light square. Soon you'll want a pawn on e6 to hold it, and then your bishop on c8 will be behind two pawns on its own colour.
So the bishop goes first.
Bishop or knight?
The two are worth about the same, and that "about" hides a great deal. Which is better depends on the pawns.
- Open positions suit bishops. With pawns swapped off and long diagonals clear, a bishop crosses the board in one move, and can work on both sides of it at once. A knight needs four moves to get from one wing to the other.
- Closed positions suit knights. When the pawns are locked together, the bishop's diagonals are blocked and the knight jumps over the lot, especially from a square where no pawn can attack it. The next lesson is about those squares.
- Two bishops together cover both colours, and neither has the weakness of one alone. In an open position the pair is usually worth a little more than a bishop and a knight, or two knights.
So think before swapping a bishop for a knight just because you can: ask which of them the pawns are going to suit.
Try it: which trade?
If you have a bad bishop, the simplest cure is to swap it off. If you have the good one, hold on to it. That's your worst piece for their best again.
These are rules of thumb. Stockfish would call both positions close to level today. The difference shows twenty moves later, when one side has a piece that works and the other doesn't.
Living with your bishops
- Put your centre pawns on the other colour from your bishop, when you have the choice.
- Get the bishop outside before a pawn move shuts it in.
- Swap a bad bishop off when you can, and keep a good one.
- Open the position when you have the bishops, and keep it closed when you have the knights.
- A bad bishop still guards good pawns. It isn't lost, only passive, and plenty of games are held by one. Don't panic about it. Do count it when you look for your worst piece.
Shapeshifter, in the games, is a good way to feel what each piece can and can't reach, and Play the engine lets you start from a closed opening or an open one and see which pieces come to life.