Learn Strategy Lesson 6 of 8

When to trade

A fair trade isn't always a good one. Trade pieces when you're ahead and pawns when you're behind, and your worst piece for their best.

No trade is neutral

A knight for a knight, a rook for a rook: the count stays level, so it's easy to think nothing has happened. Something always has. The pieces that are left matter more, the kings are a little safer, and whoever was better is now better by a different amount.

You already know what the pieces are worth, and so whether a trade is fair. This lesson is about the other question: when a trade is fair, do you want it?

There are four rules of thumb. The first is the most valuable thing in this whole level.

Ahead? Trade pieces

Here White has an extra pawn, with a rook each. An extra pawn sounds like it should win, and the bar says otherwise: 53 in a hundred. With rooks on the board, the defender has checks, threats and counter-attacks, and four pawns against three on one side is very hard to win.

A pawn up, with rooks on: 53%.

Now take the rooks off, and change nothing else. The same pawns, the same kings, the same extra pawn: 88 in a hundred.

Don't take the numbers on trust. Each board has a button to play its position out against Stockfish: try to win the one with rooks, and then the one without.

That's the rule: when you're ahead in material, trade pieces. Every pair that comes off makes your extra material a bigger share of what's left, and takes away something the defender could have fought back with.

It's pieces you want to trade, and not pawns. You'll need your pawns to make a queen.

The same position without the rooks: 88%.

Try it: the trade that wins

You're a pawn up again, with a rook each, and your extra pawn is a passed pawn a long way from the kings. Black's rook stands in front of it, guarded by the king.

Try three moves: the trade of rooks, a move that keeps the rooks on, and anything else. Watch the bar.

White to move.

Behind? Trade pawns

Turn it round. If you're the one who's behind, you want the opposite: keep the pieces on, and trade pawns.

Pieces give you chances to fight back. And pawns are what your opponent needs to win, because in the end somebody has to make a queen. Take the last pawn away and a great deal of extra material is worth nothing: a king and a bishop can't give checkmate, and neither can a king and a knight.

A whole bishop up, and no pawns: 50%. It can't be won.

Try it: the last pawn

You're Black, a knight down, and White's last pawn is one step from becoming a queen. If it does, the game is over.

You have a bishop. What's it worth, compared with that pawn?

Black to move. You're playing from Black's side.

Attacking? Keep them on

The third rule is about kings. An attack needs attackers, and a queen most of all.

  • If you're attacking, don't trade the pieces that are doing it, however fair the trade. Three pieces round a king are dangerous, and two usually aren't.
  • If you're being attacked, offer trades, the queens first. Each attacker that comes off makes your king safer, and it's often worth a pawn to get the queens off.
  • If your own king is the less safe one, you're the one who wants the queens off, even when nobody is attacking yet.

Your worst for their best

The last rule joins up with the first lesson of this level. Pieces of the same kind aren't worth the same on the board, so a trade that's level by the numbers can be a bargain.

Here both sides have a bishop and a knight. White's bishop is shut in behind its own pawns, which stand on squares of its colour: a bad bishop. Black's knight sits on a square in the middle where no pawn can touch it.

White wants that knight gone, and is bringing his own knight to d2 to offer a swap: knight for knight by the count, and his spare piece for Black's best by what they do. If Black lets it happen, the position changes and the numbers don't.

  • Offer your worst piece for their best.
  • Refuse to give your best piece for their worst.
The bishop, in red, looks at the back of its own pawns. The knight, in green, is the best piece on the board, so White is coming to challenge it.

Try it: trade, or keep them on?

Two positions, the same but for one knight. In each, White can swap queens or move the queen away.

White to move.

Before any trade

Ask what the board looks like afterwards, and who's happier with it.

  • Am I ahead? Then trade pieces, and keep pawns.
  • Am I behind? Then keep pieces, and trade pawns.
  • Whose king is in more danger? That side wants the queens off.
  • Which piece is better, the one I'm giving or the one I'm getting?

Fair trade, in the games, drills whether a swap is level, and Finish the job starts you ahead and asks you to win, which is this lesson against Stockfish. A report gives your accuracy in the opening, the middlegame and the endgame separately, so you can see whether your leads are slipping once the pieces start to come off.