Learn Openings Lesson 11 of 11

When they leave the book

Your opponent plays a move you've never seen. Is it a threat, a mistake or just a move? Two questions that tell you.

It happens by move five

You've learnt an opening. You know its moves and the reasons for them. Then, a few moves into a real game, your opponent plays something that wasn't in the lesson.

This isn't bad luck. It's every game. Nobody's memory reaches further than a few moves against every reply, and most of your opponents haven't studied the lines you have.

There are two ways to get it wrong:

  • "It's not in the book, so it must be a blunder." Then you go looking for a punishment that isn't there, and give something away trying to make one work.
  • "I don't know this, so I'm in trouble." Then you play timidly against a move that deserved no respect.

The book has run out, and what's left is why its moves were good in the first place. This lesson is what to do next.

Try it: three kinds of surprise

An unexpected move is one of three things. It threatens something, and has to be answered. It's a mistake that can be punished right now. Or, most often, it's just a move: not the best, not losing, and no reason to change your plans.

Three surprises. Say which kind each is, and then see what Stockfish made of the position.

What kind of move was it?

Two questions

When the surprise comes, stop. This is the moment in the opening that deserves your time. Then ask two things, in this order.

  • What does it threaten? Run through the other side's checks, captures and threats as if it were their move again. If something is hanging, deal with that first.
  • What has it stopped doing? Every move leaves something behind. A piece that moved was guarding something. A pawn that moved has left squares it can never guard again. A move spent on the edge wasn't spent on the centre, on development or on the king.

If the first answer is "nothing" and the second gives you a target, look for the punishment, starting with your own forcing moves. If neither gives you anything, play the move the principles would have you play anyway. That's the usual case, and it's a good outcome: you're a move ahead.

Try it: the move that does nothing

You're playing the Italian Game. Black's third move is the h-pawn, one square. It's probably the commonest odd move in club chess, played to keep your knight out of g5.

It isn't in your book. Is there a way to punish it? Try three moves: one that goes straight for the king, one ordinary developing move, and anything else you like.

White to move. Black has just played the h-pawn.

Nine different moves cost White less than five points here, and castling is as good as any of them. Every attempt to punish the pawn move at once loses a piece.

So what did Black's move cost? A little, and only if you use it: White is at 55 in a hundred, a touch better than at the start of the game. Black has spent a move that developed nothing, and you collect by developing. An advantage in time doesn't win material by itself. It gives you the better game ten moves later.

Try it: the move that loses

This one is different. On move two, Black has guarded the e-pawn with the f-pawn. It looks solid.

Ask the second question: what has it stopped doing? The f-pawn was part of the wall in front of Black's king. With it gone, the diagonal from h5 to the king is open, and there's nothing to block it with but another pawn.

That's a target, so look at your forcing moves. One of your captures seems to lose a knight for a pawn.

White to move.

Try it: an opening you've never studied

The same thinking works against a whole opening you don't know. Here Black has answered your king's pawn by pushing the d-pawn two squares, you've taken it, and the queen has taken back.

That's a real opening, and a respectable one. You don't need to have read about it. The queen is in the middle of the board on move two, and one of the first things you learnt about openings was what happens to a queen who comes out early.

White to move.

After the game

During the game, principles are all you have, and they're enough. Afterwards you can do better, and this is how an opening really gets learnt: one surprise at a time.

  • Find the move where you left what you knew. It's usually earlier than you think.
  • See what should have been played there, and say the reason for it in words.
  • Add that one move to what you know. Next time, the surprise comes a move later.

By the book, in the games, does exactly this: you play an opening against the replies people really make, and the moment you leave the book it shows you the book's moves, how many players choose each and what Stockfish makes of them. The openings part of a report does it for your own games: your results in every line you've played as a tree, move by move, so that a reply you keep losing to stands out however the games went afterwards.